191 Comments

Thank you for the Democracy Index and giving us this thoughtful post about it. We desperately need a tool to keep focused on what matters most right now, and the DI is that tool.

Expand full comment

I've been wondering when the Democracy Index would make an appearance ever since Joyce said she was working on the project. I'm so glad it's almost up and running! Once it's available, I will let my friends and family know. It's a great idea and will be a GREAT RESOURCE. Thank you Joyce Vance!!!

Expand full comment

Thank you, just what we need.

Expand full comment

I have said this before, and it is only more apparent by the day. tRump is pushing to end America. Why? Because that will make him a singular person in history. One and only. THAT is HIS end goal and the rest of us can suck eggs.

It has already started with the blatant disregard for court orders. Next is martial law and suspending the midterms.

Mark my words.

Expand full comment

Yes, Trump wants America to become Putin's Russia where Trump is the lifetime leader and the American oligarchs are his power. Along with the six Christian Nationalists on the Supreme Court, Trump is making America an authoritarian theocracy.

Expand full comment

It’s much, much worse than that. Trump is a psychopath who only lives to hurt as many people as possible: inflicting cruelty is the while point of everything he does. We need to come to grips with the terrifying realization that the cruelty and destruction are intentional and will get much, much worse before we finally stop him. In his warped brain, his entire reason for being is to destroy everything and everyone he can. He’s like a vampire feeding on the blood of Americans until they die, with the sole aim of staying alive so he can drink more blood, leaving a trail of purposeful destruction in his wake. He will never stop on his own. That’s it. That’s the whole thing. The rest of it is just mechanisms toward this end. There are going to be a lot of bodies, both figurative and literal, before he’s done.

Expand full comment

This is the absolute truth! His psychopathy leads him to destroy human beings and usurp their needs to satisfy his own lack of self and empathy. That’s what makes him feel powerful. Taking the government down is icing on the cake!

Expand full comment

Except, the Project 2025 inception was long before PINO came into the picture. The forces behind it are the many, many billionaires that formed foundations and made long range plans for just this time. All they needed was a charismatic figurehead to put the plan in place. There are many, many others holding the reins here and they have a well trained steed.

Expand full comment

one other note. The Devos mercenaries are guarding our government's departments while they are being shredded. Rich people's private army.

Expand full comment

The courts need to send in Federal Marshals to get our congress members past them and begin to see what is being done.

Expand full comment

This is true, and why it will outlast Trump the Tool

Expand full comment

We can only imagine the damage he is doing to his grandchildren...at least 1 of them was at the super(?)bowl yesterday. His children are pathetic already

Expand full comment

Aesop, I have tried to communicate to family and friends what you have stated above, and I get back that look like maybe you are a little over the top. I used the exact phrase, "mark my words". Don't forget about internment camps popping up.

Expand full comment

I don't doubt for one second that that is the MAGAites' and their Dear Leader's intention. I just won't concede it as inevitable. I'm convinced more and more by the day that, just as obeying in advance isn't an option, resigning to it in advance also benefits no one.

Expand full comment

I agree. I am tired of the doomsayers. Yeah, Trump (and Elon) are sociopaths, but that does not mean that any particular outcome is inevitable. Aesop's tales are ego talking. I am here to figure out what we need to focus our energies on, and what we can do to get in the way. Not interested in spending time wringing hands.

Expand full comment

My thinking as well.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Joyce! You're a rockstar!!

Expand full comment

WaPo's buried article...re: Trump is having each candidate for jobs in his administration's FBI field stations away from DC answer 'Who's your boss?" "Who were the real patriots on January 6th?"

Questions posed to leadership positions WITHIN his national security apparatus in Washington were told to answer yes or no: 1. Was January 6th and inside job? 2. Was the 2020 presidential election stolen? 2 applicants told their interviews 'no'. They weren't hired.

The past 21 days have been shit storm. WTF. Why hell aren't democrats going on Fox Sunday Shows and talking about that? About Muck the SS numbers?

I'm resisting but with that report from WaPo scares me more than anything. What's to stop them from checking every single voter registrations across the country and jailing anyone with a D next to their name?

Expand full comment

I wrote WaPo requesting a Bluesky link. No reply!!

Expand full comment

Who at WaPo? Link to what?

Expand full comment

I used the "contact us" link to request WaPo enable posting of articles on Bluesky. WaPo indicated a reply forthcoming but nothing. It posts some on Bluesky but not timely articles. I lost X account when I had to clear cache and didn't reconnect correctly.

Expand full comment

I just sent another request that we subscription holders be permitted to post on Bluesky.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this Democracy Index project! It is exactly what we need as the abyss's between our democracy and Trump's intended Totalitarian rule. Too many neither read Project 2025 or Agenda 47, so they were caught by surprise. I, too, am watching how rapidly PINO and Musk are causing chaos daily.

Expand full comment

Republicans......led by Trump.......are an enemy of America, and.....we are under Attack!

Expand full comment

I keep thinking the same. With all the discussion about and criticism of democrats and how they will win back the working class, I keep thinking, what about all those republicans in the senate and congress that actually do have the power to stop this? They are truly the guilty ones. They could have voted to convict after Trump was impeached. And they can still stop him now starting with blocking his cabinet picks. I'm not sure I buy the the excuse that they are being threatened and are afraid to go against Trump. I think they are mostly, if not all, lockstep with him.

Expand full comment

Exactly! What are they so afraid of? Having to get a REAL job?

Expand full comment

"Until then, remember that staying informed and having a community are powerful acts in support of democracy."

With whatever regard the Washington Post may be due, to be clear, democracy dies in silence.

And when it comes to making noise, the true power of the pen is not in opinions or essays or indices. The power is the clarion call to action.

I suscribed to the Contrarian in anticipation that there would soon be a banner calling for the necessary action which, to my limited 1960's way of thinking, would at least be a strike of federal workers that shuts down the Trump/Musk government.

Make noise.

Expand full comment

Thank you. Citizen action is required. If we remain victims, we fail.

Expand full comment

I also subscribe to Hopium Chronicles where Simon Rosenberg, former DNC strategist, gives daily action items. We can't just read what's happening, we have to respond in a constructive, strategic way. Hopium provides that.

Expand full comment

Ms. Vance: Thank you for all the work you put into your posts, and for this recent Substack submission. We always enjoyed your professional commentary on MSNBC and now (that we no longer watch it) are faithful readers. As my Aunt Elizabeth would say, “Ever forward!”

Expand full comment

I'm at the "Everything They Do Is Awful and Dangerous" stage. Are there any consequences when Trusk ignores decisions by judges? If not, what do us mere mortals do? I suggest stories about actual consequences being experienced by folks in red states would be a good idea. Media needs to go personal. People who voted for this WH need to see how they're going to get screwed.

Expand full comment

In normal times, the consequences of not complying with court orders could be arrest by federal marshals. But guess who is now in charge of the federal marshals?

Expand full comment

Absolutely.

Expand full comment

"Trusk." Good moniker.

Expand full comment

Yet another positive for being part of The Contrarian community. Thank you.

Expand full comment

So wish I had skills that I could contribute to your work, but the Democracy Index will help me stay sane! I am encouraged that my most significant concerns are reflected in your summary. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Who will be America's enforcers? Federal Marshalls? CIA/FBI on internal "domestic terrorism"? We must call this what it is ---citizens of Hungary, citizens of Nicaragua, citizens of Venezuela --have seen this playbook. Dems/Ind. ---been outplayed again & again. DJT will not obey court orders --be aware!

Expand full comment

Can't remember where I read it or I would link, but the question of enforcement starts with fines, I read, applied in doubling, meaning a thousand dollars the first day, 2 thousand the second 4 thousand the third, etc. Pocket change for Musk but not for those kids. Will he pay his fines and all of theirs and continue to thumb his nose? Well, then there is the possibility of "contempt" enforcement but that's when we run into Trump owning law enforcement now or soon in the future. Impossible to say what happens or at what point the Republicans via their constituents might wake up.

Expand full comment

The 2024 election saw the American voter turn his country over to an Autocratic Fascist. Worse, these same voters gave him majorities in both the House and Senate.

We are now getting what we asked for. I do not believe democracy will make it for two more years. I believe it will be dismantled.

Our courts, I feel, is the only thing that stands against a successful Project 2025.

Expand full comment

Remember, this is happening:

The 24 HOUR ECONOMIC BLACKOUT!

As our first initial act, we turn it off.

For just one day we show them who really holds the power.

WHEN:

Friday. February 28th from 12:00 AM to 11:59

PM, the last day of this month.

WHAT NOT TO DO:

Do not make any purchases unless urgent.

Do not shop online, or in-store, or via delivery.

No Amazon, No Walmart, No Best Buy, Nowhere!

Do not spend money on:

Fast Food

Gas

Major Retailers

Do not use Credit or Debit Cards for nonessential spending.

WHAT YOU CAN DO:

Only buy essentials of absolutely necessary:

(Food, Medicine, Emergency Supplies)

ONLY support small, local businesses

Expand full comment

This is my life already! Mostly out of necessity now, but it is actually a choice I made a long time ago. Local is hard where I live, and we have to use online order, but we pick small businesses or traditional businesses as much as possible (our needs are simple). So the 28th will be easy to work in!

Expand full comment

Hope it catches on. Sounds like the warm up to large scale pressure on GOP to not “go along to get along”

Expand full comment

Spread the word!

Expand full comment

https://stopproject2025comic.org/wp-content/uploads/STOP_P2025_COMIC_BOOK.pdf?

Feel free to pass this along to all of your comic book-loving friends and family members. Heck, even perfect strangers

Expand full comment

Looks great. Thank you for sharing.I only wish people creating these types of materials would stop putting chump's ugly face on the content. Some of us have such a visceral reaction to seeing him we slam our eyes shut and can't go any further.

Expand full comment

way too many words for those who really need to see and understand it.

Expand full comment

Too many words in Project 2025 for those who will be affected by it in some way, as well. And there is at least one thing in P2025 that will piss off anyone in the US.

Expand full comment